Climate and Health Benefits of Electric School Buses: A Financial Analysis

Climate and Health Benefits of Electric School Buses: A Financial Analysis

A recent study published in the journal PNAS reveals that transitioning from diesel to electric school buses could bring substantial health and climate benefits, with significant financial implications. This groundbreaking research quantifies the advantages of replacing diesel-powered school buses with electric models across 3,108 U.S. counties, offering a detailed economic perspective on the benefits of electrification.

The United States relies heavily on its fleet of half a million school buses, many of which are older, highly polluting diesel vehicles. While emissions regulations have reduced pollution from newer models, older diesel buses remain a significant source of harmful emissions. As of June 2023, only 2,277 electric school buses had been ordered, delivered, or were in operation nationwide.

Quantifying the Benefits

The study estimates that replacing an average diesel bus with an electric one would yield a per-bus benefit of $84,200, divided almost equally between health and climate improvements. This shift would cut approximately 181 metric tons of carbon dioxide emissions per bus and significantly reduce the incidence of childhood asthma and related deaths due to diesel emissions.

Urban vs. Rural Impact

The benefits of electrification vary significantly by location. In dense metropolitan areas, the benefits per bus could reach up to $247,600, reflecting the higher population density and greater exposure to harmful emissions. In contrast, the impact in rural areas is less pronounced due to lower population density.

Despite the higher upfront costs of electric school buses—averaging $156,000 more than diesel buses over their lifetime—the study argues that the long-term health and environmental savings, particularly in urban areas, justify the investment. "In a dense urban setting where old diesel buses still comprise most school bus fleets, the savings incurred from electrifying these buses outweigh the costs of replacement," says Kari Nadeau, a senior author of the study and a professor at the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health.

Social Equity and Health

The research highlights that Black, Hispanic, and low-income communities in large metropolitan areas would experience the most significant health benefits from this transition. These groups are disproportionately affected by air pollution and stand to gain the most from cleaner, electric school buses.

The study calls for further research into the exposure of children to particulate pollution inside the buses, as data on in-cabin pollution is still emerging.

Conclusion

Transitioning to electric school buses offers a clear pathway to improving public health and combating climate change. While the initial costs are higher, the long-term benefits in terms of reduced emissions, better health outcomes, and financial savings make a compelling case for policymakers and communities to accelerate the adoption of electric school buses.

 A study published in the journal PNAS quantifies the health and climate benefits of replacing diesel school buses with electric ones in the U.S. Researchers found that switching to electric buses could provide significant health and climate advantages, with an average benefit of $84,200 per bus. This includes reductions in carbon dioxide emissions and improvements in childhood health. The study highlights that the benefits are more substantial in densely populated urban areas. Despite higher upfront costs, the long-term savings and health improvements, particularly for marginalized communities, make the switch advantageous.

FAQs

What is the main finding of the study on electric school buses? The study found that replacing diesel school buses with electric ones could yield significant health and climate benefits, estimated at $84,200 per bus.

What are the primary benefits of switching to electric school buses? Benefits include a reduction in carbon dioxide emissions and a decrease in childhood asthma cases and deaths related to diesel pollution.

How do the benefits of electric school buses vary by location? Benefits are higher in densely populated urban areas due to greater exposure to diesel emissions, while rural areas see smaller impacts.

What are the cost considerations for electric school buses? Electric school buses are more expensive upfront, costing about $156,000 more than diesel buses over their lifetime, but the long-term health and climate benefits can outweigh these costs.

Who stands to benefit the most from the transition to electric school buses? Black, Hispanic, and low-income communities in large metropolitan areas are likely to experience the greatest health benefits from the transition.

1. #ClimateChange
2. #ElectricVehicles
3. #SchoolBuses
4. #PublicHealth
5. #SustainableTransport